He used to get the Wellness grain-free chicken, turkey, beef & chicken, turkey & salmon along with the Nature's Variety, Weruva & raw listed below. After the recall I can't find any Wellness that DON'T have "7W" on the bottom of the can and he won't eat those (though he'll make an exception, with encouragement, for the turkey & salmon. I only feed that every couple weeks).
Currently he's getting (all wet):
Nature's Variety Instinct rabbit, venison, (had to stop the lamb--he may be developing an allergy to it), chicken, duck
Natural Balance Limited Ingredient Diet chicken & green pea (this is grain free)
Go! chicken/turkey/duck (grainfree)
Weruva grain-free chicken flavors only. I don't like feeding fish too much, though the Natural Balance has some salmon oil in it. He gets the Weruva as a snack before bedtime, just a forkful or so. Otherwise he gets so worked up he may bring it up for another look.
Raw chicken hearts and gizzards, once a week or so to keep his teeth clean.
Why I feed the above? Mainly because it’s grain-free and he’ll eat it. I keep trying other brands (Evo, Merrick, Dave’s) and he’s just not interested. I keep hoping to find something else to add to the rotation. He will eat the other Natural Balance Ltd Ingredient Diets, but the other flavors are duck (he doesn’t get too excited) and venison, and I still remember a homeopathic vet telling me venison is “hot.” So is lamb, and since he seemed to be having a problem with the lamb I thought it best to limit the exposure to venison.
Katie, I agree with Lola -- my first thought was the dry food may be hurting her teeth/gums. If she’ll eat it, wet should be easier on her teeth, esp. if it’s pate. Pookie was/is a grazer, too – he’ll eat half the wet, walk off and eat more later. It’s okay to leave the wet down for a while. I leave it out all day/night but he usually finishes it within an hour unless he’s not interested. When I first took him off the dry, he’d walk by where the feeder was and look for it, but he stopped after a while. Maybe because I kept telling him he was never getting that stuff again.
I’ve never used the fortiflora, so can’t add anything there. Sorry.