By Nature Organics is carrageenan free. The website,
and the can labels have the correct ingredients listed. The on line stores who sell the food have not been updated.
The By Nature 95% is not carrageenan free. By Nature has one new formula, "Entrees Cat Food" that is carrageenan free and menadione free, BUT it is not vegetable matter free (grains and/or fruits and veggies). Their other new formula "Artisan" contains carrageenan and fruits and vegetables.
I couldn't believe they still have some of those discontinued cases. I placed one more order, the shipnow code is still good too. I now have enough By Nature Organic to last me one year, and I got it all for half price.