I feed raw but keep canned on hand mostly for emergency situations. Sometimes I go out of town for a weekend or so, and the person feeding her can't be bothered to thaw out her raw. Sometimes a batch of raw food runs out at an inopportune time, and she eats canned for a day or two until I have the time and ingredients to make her more food.
My top choice is currently the by Nature 95% meat line, and I buy all four flavors: Chicken, Turkey, Beef, and occasionally the Sardine and Mackerel, which she never gets more than twice in any given month. I have to order this online, via PetFlow or Petfooddirect. I used to feed all the EVO 95% meat varieties, which I also had to order online, but since the P&G takeover, I don't allow it in the house anymore. I used to purchase the Natural balance Venison & Green Pea and Duck & Green Pea varieties, but now they are having issues, so they have been removed as viable options. My second choice is now the Before Grain 96% line, and she has eaten all of their flavors as well. I can buy this at the local Petco when I am not able to order her food online. When I have to stick to foods I can buy at Wal-Mart or the Commissary, she gets Newman's Own Organics Chicken & Salmon, Chicken & Rice, Turkey, and/or Turkey & Vegetable or the non-seafood Natural Life flavors because, and I know I am going to get bashed for this, I would rather feed her food without byproducts and other questionable ingredients and with some grain that food with byproducts and without grains. Neither the Newman's Own or the Natural Life contains by-products, unspecified meats, BHT, BHA, ethoxyquin, or menadione, corn, wheat, soy, or _____ gluten. And like I said, this stuff doesn't exactly play a large part in her diet, but even if it did, my position on the byproducts/unnamed meat sources/carcinogens would be the same.
When she was a kitten, before I knew to avoid fish-based foods as a primary diet, she got the Pinnacle Chicken & Tuna and Chicken & Oceanfish varieties.
As for B&J ice cream, my favorite flavors are Coffee Heathbar Crunch, Peanut butter Cup, Everything But the..., Mud Pie, and Half-baked, in that order. I want to try Bonnard's Buzz.