That's funny.... you hating Fresh and Light. I don't think I saw other options, at the store I was at. I'll double check on my next visit.
So far, no "mush" or scooping issues. BUT maybe I have the scooper of all scoopers! lol (Referring to the other thread about missing scoop.)
I just have regular throw rugs, under all the boxes. I have to stick to using a particular kind of rug, or my red boy uses them for scratching. Yes, I could train/direct him elsewhere, but...
The boxes, with lids, the cats step out and in the direction of the rug... most litter stops there. The boxes with no lids... the cats can leave from any angle... the rugs only "catch" so much.
Our oldest cat paws at a box for about 10 minutes. NO litter leaves the box, when she is done.