I like the Soulistic though it's sort of low in protein and very low in calories, and I have only once cat who can/will eat it. She gets it once every 10 days or so, to help keep her slim and trim. She also gets Wervua nine livers once a week for the same reason.
Soulistic Good Karma chicken is the the only one I feed. The rest have some sort of fish also, and I don't feed fish.My Sweet Boy Bridge Angel really loved the Soulistic Good Karma Chicken. Little Cat loves it too, but it gives her diarrhea and the other girl, newly put on a canned diet (from prescription c/d) won't eat it.